Saturday, July 10, 2010

TaTa DoCoMo Vs VODAFONE IN EGDE (2.5G) speed Test


The bidding of 3G services is now completed.
The spectrum of 3G is purchased by the Networks spending many crores depending on circles covered!
Even then all the networks could not cover all the circles!
But it takes some time for the 3G services to be started by these Networks!
Meanwhile the GPRS or DATA Tariff war is getting hot day by day.
This is a Test in AP CIRCLE circle to perform the SPEED TEST to check the performance of both TATA DOCOMO and VODAFONE IN.
As known the speed of an internet connection on a computer can be tested, likewise the speed on mobile can be Tested using    http://mobilespeedtest.com/  .
All statistics depend on the results performed using that site.
(They send 100kb from mobile to their server and measure how much time it consumes in that process)
I decided to conduct tests at 3 different timings as conducted before with 3 timings even in this circle too.(Morning, Afternoon, Midnight)
The Results are a bit varying so i decided to post 2 tests for every time slot of both operators.


The screenshots of the test performed in the morning session are shown below.


                           TATADOCOMO SPEED TEST AT MORNING 9:00AM (Dated 24/6/2010)

            
        Test1:78.895Kbps         Test 2:66.778Kbps


                                        VODAFONE IN SPEED TEST RESULT AT MORNING 8:40AM


                              Test 1:21.882Kbps    Test2:30.008Kbps

The tests performed clearly show us that TATA DOCOMO gave a whooping speed on an average of 72.8365Kbps  when taken average of two tests while Vodafone gave an ordinary speed of  25.945Kbps when the average of two tests is taken.

WINNER morning session: TATA DOCOMO SPEED: 72.8365Kbps



The screenshots of the test performed in the afternoon session are shown below.



                  TATADOCOMO SPEED TEST on AFTERNOON 3:00PM (Dated 24/6/2010)

 Test 1:70.299Kbps               Test 2:98.039Kbps

We decided to test at 3PM because usually considering 12AM to 2PM are the lunch hours.



                           VODAFONE SPEED-TEST on AFTERNOON 3:05PM (Dated 24/6/2010)



                     Test 1:16.546Kbps            
                     Test 2:36.199Kbps


The tests performed clearly show us that TATA DOCOMO gave a whooping speed on an average of 84.169Kbps  when taken average of two tests while Vodafone gave an ordinary speed of  26.3725Kbps when the average of two tests is taken.


WINNER AFTERNOON TEST: TATA DOCOMO SPEED: 84.169Kbps


The screenshots of the test performed in the Midnight session are shown below:


                        TATADOCOMO SPEED TEST MIDNIGHT 1:00am (Dated 25/6/2010)

                              Test 1:75.188Kbps      Test 2:93.897Kbps







                    VODAFONE SPEEDTEST MIDNIGHT 1:05AM (Dated 25/6/2010)



                          Test 1:66.946Kbps        
                          Test 2:60.698Kbps

The tests performed clearly show us that TATA DOCOMO gave a whooping speed on an average of 84.5425Kbps  when taken average of two tests while Vodafone gave an ordinary speed of  63.822Kbps when the average of two tests is taken.

WINNER MIDNIGHT SESSION: TATADOCOMO SPEED: 84.5425Kbps


We can clearly see from the results that the speed of Tata DoCoMo is maintained constant at all the times of the day and it has the best speed when compared to VODAFONE IN.
VODAFONE IN speed test results indicate that Vodafone have varying speeds at different times of the day.
To analyze in a better i'm planning to compare all the remaining operators at different times soon.

Speed test was done with NOKIA N97Mini using Mobilespeedtest.com using the Symbian S60 5th Edition default browser.

Test conducted at 
Shivaji nagar,
Secunderabad city,
Andhra Pradesh.


More tests to follow soon at my fav Blog TT !

No comments:

Post a Comment